Jay bio gallery
WTC 9/11/01 & On

Photographs


Writings Etc.

08/03/03: A Photograph of Ground Zero

09/10/02: Building Downtown.

04/10/02: Remembrance and Renewal.

01/12/02: Visiting Zero.

09/24/01: The gloom that is NYC.

09/14/01: Three days later.

09/11/01: The disturbing act of posing for snapshots.

09/10/02: Building Downtown

A few months ago Image NY brought together the paticipants from it's public forums for the future of downtown NYC. What was striking at the meeting was the range of ideas for what should be done at the site and the passion of the community that it not be rushed and built by bureaucrats.

I had a very difficult time not feeling cynical about what would happen. There was so much invested in such a relatively small area of real estate and the demands that were placed on it seemed overwhelming. The site needed to be a museum, a memorial, office space, residences, affordable housing, open green space, transit hub, school, retail, etc. If it didn't end up being a Ground Zero theme park, it could possibly become an uninspiring collection of boxes that only served functions.

Then the Lower Manhattan Development Corp. released it's concept plans for downtown and confirmed that lack of artistic vision. With their six similar design studies, LMDC showed no creative direction for the project and instead constructed an assemblage of square footage. How could New York city not be consulting with it's vast array of architectural talent to produce a new, inspiring plan for downtown and work to create a new landmark for people around the world? The plans were dismissed by much of the community.

The New York Time's architecture critic, Herbert Muschamp, rose to the challenge and assembled a panel of innovative architects to create a master plan for downtown. It's unbelievable that the LMDC didn't work with these architects from the get go. The designs the NY Times charette came up with are fanciful and fantastic. The presentation allows an openness for an exploration of urban and architectural ideas that I hope city planners are listening to. NYC deserves it.

See Reimagining Ground Zero at the New York Times web site